What is it like to negotiate with Moscow's officials concerning the war in Ukraine?
This question has piqued widespread interest following multiple recent sessions of ceasefire talks, which have so far appeared to produce little fruit half a decade after the full-scale military offensive.
A further phase of US-mediated negotiations is likely to take place in Geneva later this week. In preparation, a key participant of the Ukrainian leadership's delegation, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has taken part in the latest military-to-military talks, has shared his perspective.
According to Kyslytsya, these interactions are business-like and generally free of the type of ideological and historical grandstanding observed in other forums by Moscow.
"The military have a better understanding of what is going on in the battlefield," he remarked during a conversation on Monday morning.
"The question remains if they [the Russians] are able, or not, of reporting [back] accurately…without altering or distorting the information," he added.
It is not an simple thing to try to end a major conflict. The reality of the front line in eastern Ukraine - where tens of thousands of unmanned aerial vehicles operate and kill over a huge so-called "contested area" between the two sides, while two hundred thousand local residents still reside in the "fortress belt" urban areas of the Donbas - makes the practical business of separation extremely complicated.
"It is essential to establish a clear framework of rules and procedures," Kyslytsya said, "along with a way to verify and oversee."
The Role of External Parties
A great deal of these preparations, he noted, is finished, thanks in part to the direct participation of American representatives, such as General Alexus Grynkewich and Dan Driscoll.
It's obviously not in Kyiv's interest to disparage representatives of the American government, but when he compliments the American team for its efforts, he sounds genuine.
"We must credit the US side for their commitment and their patience," he says, "since they attend the sessions non-stop. They not only observe…they ask questions and they heed our responses."
Kyslytsya was similarly complimentary about the contributions of the former president's adviser, whom he described as "experienced", and billionaire mediator Steve Witkoff, whom he characterized as "a much wiser person than the caricature image often presented in the press".
The US, he asserted, will undertake a critical role in monitoring any potential truce, with resources including orbital and other types of advanced monitoring.
"We need someone who will play the role of adjudication, for the reason that if there is a violation there must be a third party that is reliable [and] authoritative."
Previous and Current Oversight Challenges
During an eight-year period before Russia's major invasion in recent years, this oversight function was handled by the OSCE - a group whose limited means and lack of enforcement mechanisms made it mostly incapable of averting an escalation.
"That was quite an achievement [for them] just to operate two UAVs airborne above the territory," he commented. "It resembles the Flintstones era compared to what we have now."
In comparison, latest analyses suggest that as many as twelve thousand unmanned aircraft are active above the urban center of a frontline city at any given moment.
A Personal Perspective on Facing the Opposition
Inquired how he managed to negotiate directly from delegates representing a leader in the Russian government who has shown readiness to sacrifice over a million-plus of his country's soldiers to conquer its neighbor, Kyslytsya, with extensive UN experience, provided his answer.
He explained that he'd had years of experience.
"I witnessed much worse. I spent a five-year term in at the UN, a portion before the full-scale invasion. I regularly had to sit in the room with the adversary on a regular basis."
One evening is seared in his memory: 23 February 2022.
In the middle of an urgent Security Council session, convened to address the looming threat in the country, the diplomat received news that his homeland was being assaulted.
Simultaneously, seven time zones to the east in the capital, the first far-off explosions signaled as the total attack on Ukraine began.
Amid moments of intense tension, Kyslytsya attempted to get his Russian counterpart, Vassily Nebenzia, to call his boss, the Russian foreign minister, to obtain guarantees that Russian forces would not invade.
"I have stated all that I am aware of today," the Russian diplomat responded, as recalled by Kyslytsya. "I'm not going to wake Minister Lavrov at this hour."
Everyone's lives changed at that instant. The diplomat remained at the United Nations for another three years prior to returning to Kyiv.
The Path Forward
If the negotiating teams reconvene in Geneva this week, he will participate, still thrashing out the contours and mechanics of a halt in fighting but waiting all the while for the crucial part of the jigsaw to be resolved.
"Hostilities could be ended by just one call of an individual to his top general," he stated.
"But apparently, the Kremlin dictator [Vladimir Putin] is not prepared for stopping the conflict at present."